Everything butter + sugar makes is delicious, but there are a few things that are far and away customer favorites. Find these items in the “Mix ‘n Match” section of our online shop. Select at least $8 worth of items to round out a custom sampler of treats that you can pick up as early as next day. Can’t pick-up? Contact us for delivery options!
So, you’re pretty special and you’re looking for something a little more special. We get it! Check out the “Special Order” section of our online shop to see what we can make you. Special orders require one week’s notice to fulfill, so dream big and plan ahead! Special orders cannot be paid for online. Payment will be required when order is received.
special order banana pudding-- family style/ $45, 12 individual servings/ $55
special order banana pudding-- family style/ $45, 12 individual servings/ $55
“here’s nothing healthy about butter + sugar’s banana pudding, but there is everything delicious about this creamy indulgent dessert. A fun alternative to cupcakes or cake, our banana pudding is sweet and full of fresh banana flavor. Available to serve 10-12 family-style ($45) or can be made into 12-individual servings ($55). Please specify if you are interested in the family-style version or individual serving presentation in the Pre-Order Inquiry Form below.
CONTAINS MILK, EGG
PRE-ORDER INQUIRY FORM (required for all special orders)
We take pride in crafting each order with care, so we ask for one week's notice for all Special Orders. Please complete this form to let us know when you'd like to receive your gluten-free custom treats. We will contact you to confirm specifics on your order— delivery/pick-up timing, any additional dietary restrictions, etc— and to be sure we can accommodate your schedule. You will hear from us within 24 hours. Thank you! We look forward to baking for you!
